Showing posts with label PRINCIPLE OF INDEMNITY. Show all posts
Showing posts with label PRINCIPLE OF INDEMNITY. Show all posts

Tuesday, January 1, 2008

THE SECOND COROLLARY OF INDEMNITY-SUBROGATION

If the principle of indemnity says that I must be restored to the condition I was before I suffered the loss, it would be wrong for me to accept an agreed sum in compensation and then continue to have any other rights as well. A few examples will illustrate this

Example 1.
My car is wrecked in an accident. I agree to accept RM40,000 in settlement of my claim. The wreck is worth RM3,500 when sold to the workshop for use as spare parts. If I received this RM3,500 as well as the RM40,000 I would be getting more than the true indemnity for my loss. The insurance company therefore steps into my shoes as owner of the wreck, and the RM3,500 returns to the pool. The word ‘subrogate’ means ‘to step into the place of’, or ‘to find a substitute for’. One could say that when they pay out the claim the insurance company inherits all the rights of the person accepting settlement of the claims. This means that they also inherit the right to sue other parties in the accident for any share of the loss which their negligence may have caused.

Example 2.
A celebrated American racehorse which had won many classic races broke his leg on a Californian track. The owner had insured the horse for $250,000 with a British insurance firm, who had take the precaution of sending a representative to the track. The owner was about to give the veterinary surgeon permission to destroy the animal when the insurance representative declared his interest. He would not permit the animal to be destroyed, and soon the rare sight of a horse with a leg in plaster could be seen in the stables where the insurance company were trying to cure the animal. They paid out the claim for the racehorse and although he never raced again he was put to stud and had many fine descendants. The insurance company eventually recovered from breeding fees more than the sum paid out, and restored to the ‘pool’ all its losses. Subrogation had taken place in the nick of time to prevent the destruction of the animal.

THE FIRST COROLLARY OF INDEMNITY-CONTRIBUTION

Suppose I insure my goods against fire for RM100,00 and suffer a loss by fire of the insured goods for that amount. I shall be indemnified for the loss and receive RM100,000 out of the pool. Suppose I insure against the loss with two or three companies, would it be fair for me to claim from each company the sum of RM100,000? Clearly it would not, for I would be restored to a better position that I was in before. This would be against public policy, for it might encourage me to cause the loss to happen, so that my condition improves.

Such double insurance is unlikely today, and the insured might even be suspected of fraudulent intent. A more usual case would be where two policies overlapped, as for example where a burglary policy and an all-risks policy exist covering the same goods. The companies concerned will contribute to the loss proportionately, the exact division depending upon the terms of the original policies. To discover whether they should pay in full, or only contribute, every claim form asks the insured ‘Is any other company interested in the goods which are the subject of this claim?’ An honest answer to this question lets the insurance company know their true position.

THE PRINCIPLE OF INDEMNITY AND LIFE ASSURANCE

The principle of indemnity cannot apply in a straightforward way to life assurance, for no sum of money can equate the loss of life. Similarly in personal accident cases the loss of a limb cannot be measured accurately in terms of money. All that these policies can do is to provide a sum of money, called the benefit payment, as compensation.

Even so the principle does have some influence. Life assurance premiums are roughly related to the way life of the person concerned, for he must be able to afford the premiums, and weekly benefits for loss of earnings after an accident are not allowed to exceed the normal, earnings of the insured.

Monday, December 31, 2007

A STORY OF INDEMNITY

The insurance companies themselves have used the example of a man who knocks over someone’s beer in a crowded pub to illustrate indemnity. Suppose I knocked over someone’s glass of beer, from which he had already taken a generous swig, in a pub. I would of course apologize, and insist on buying him another pint. In other words I would more than make up for the damage, and would restore him to a better position than he was in before. The insurance company would not be generous in this way. It would make the most careful inquiries as to how much had been drunk already, and would replace the exact quantity spilled. It is no function of the insurers to pay out more from the pool than is necessary; to do so would offend against the principle of indemnity.

PRINCIPLE NO. 3-INDEMNITY, WITH CONTRIBUTION AND SUBROGATION

The contract of insurance is one of indemnity, except in the case of life assurance and personal-accident insurance. In everyday use the word 'indemnity' means to restore someone to the position that he was in immediately before the event concerned took place. For instance, an employer undertakes to indemnify his employee if the employee is put to expense of any sort on behalf of the employer’s business. If I pay out fares, or postage for my employer he will refund the money to me.

The contract of insurance is the same, in that a person suffering a loss after insuring against it will be indemnified for the amount of the loss. He will be restored as near as possible to the condition that was in immediately before the loss occurred. Indemnity never restores us to a better position than we were in before, if it did people might fell tempted to make the loss occur. Therefore any depreciation in value suffered by the property since it was purchased new, must be take into account.

Example. A motor vehicle which originally cost RM60,000 is wrecked in an accident two years after purchase. From the current list published by the motor traders, the insurance company can see that the vehicle is now worth only RM48,000. This sum will therefore be complete compensation.